We scored 21 law firm websites in Columbus for AI search visibility. Average 74/100; 10% block at least one AI crawler. See who ChatGPT and Perplexity can actually cite.
| # | Business | Score | Main issues |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Organ Law organlegal.com | 100 | — |
| 2 | E. Ray Critchett buckeyelaw.com | 90 | no business schema |
| 3 | Jay E. Michael jaymichaellaw.com | 90 | weak headings |
| 4 | Lane Alton lanealton.com | 90 | weak headings |
| 5 | Mansell Law ohio-employmentlawyer.com | 90 | no llms.txt |
| 6 | Rutan Law defenseohio.com | 90 | no business schema |
| 7 | Taps & Sutton ohioseniorlaw.com | 90 | no llms.txt |
| 8 | Winkler Legal dirkwinklerlaw.com | 90 | no llms.txt |
| 9 | Jeremy Dodgion Attorney at Law jeremydodgionlaw.com | 85 | weak headings · thin title/description |
| 10 | Saia & Piatt splaws.com | 80 | no business schema · no FAQ content |
| 11 | Anspach Law anspachlaw.com | 75 | no business schema · weak headings · little text |
| 12 | Schiff & Associates Attorneys at Law scottschiff.com | 70 | no llms.txt · no business schema · no FAQ content |
| 13 | Stephen A. Moyer smoyerlaw.com | 70 | no llms.txt · no business schema · no FAQ content |
| 14 | Robin S. Stith robinstithlaw.com | 67 | no llms.txt · no FAQ content · weak headings |
| 15 | OSP Dog Bite Lawyers accidentlawadvocates.com | 65 | no llms.txt · no business schema · no FAQ content |
| 16 | Jump Legal - Bankruptcy Attorneys legaldebtsolutions.com | 55 | blocks AI crawlers · no llms.txt · no business schema |
| 17 | Spadafore Law spadaforelaw.com | 55 | no llms.txt · no business schema · no FAQ content |
| 18 | Wolfe Legal Services - Attorney George Wolfe ohiolaw.net | 55 | no llms.txt · no business schema · no FAQ content |
| 19 | Goodrum Law Group goodrumlawgroup.com | 50 | no llms.txt · no structured data · no business schema |
| 20 | Karen E. Hamilton karenhamiltonlaw.com | 50 | no structured data · no business schema · no FAQ content |
| 21 | Thomas Taneff Co., LPA tanefflaw.com | 45 | blocks AI crawlers · no llms.txt · no business schema |
Each website is checked automatically against ten signals that decide whether AI assistants can read and cite it: AI crawler access in robots.txt (GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot, Google-Extended), an llms.txt file, JSON-LD structured data, a LocalBusiness or Organization entity, question-and-answer content, heading structure, title and meta description, visible text depth, a sitemap and Open Graph tags. Crawler access and structured data carry the most weight. Scores reflect the homepage on the day of the check and are refreshed monthly. Business names and websites come from public directory listings.
Organ Law scores highest (100/100) among the 21 Columbus law firm websites we checked in September 2026.
Whether AI assistants (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Google AI Overviews) can read and cite a website: AI crawler access in robots.txt, llms.txt, JSON-LD structured data, business entity schema, FAQ content, heading structure, title and description, text depth, sitemap and Open Graph tags. 0–100, higher is better.
2 of 21 (10%) block at least one major AI crawler such as GPTBot, ClaudeBot or PerplexityBot, which prevents AI assistants from citing them.